I got caught up in the Kony2012 thing last week. My 18-year-old daughter sent me a link to the 27-minute video by the charity Invisible Children. I received it very early in the morning as I was contemplating sleeping for another hour.
So before I go on, I want to post this voice from Ugandan journalist Rosebell Kagumire. If you spared 27 minutes to watch Invisible Children’s Kony 2012, you can spare 6 minutes to watch this:
“This [Kony2012] is another video where I see an outsider trying to be a hero rescuing African children. We have seen these stories a lot in Ethiopia, celebrities coming in Somalia – you know it does not end the problem. I think we need sound, intelligent campaigns that are geared toward real policy shifts rather than a sensationalized story that is out to make just one person cry and then at the end of the day we forget about it …. How do you tell the story of Africans? [That’s] much more important than what the story is actually, because if you are showing me as voiceless, as hopeless you have no place telling my story. You shouldn’t be telling my story if you don’t believe that I also have the power to change what is going on.”
Right on Ms Kagumire.
Here’s what happened to me last week.
I watched the whole Kony2012 video after daughter sent it to me via Facebook. I cried. I wanted to order the Kony2012 kit right away. I was so proud of my daughter for wanting to get engaged in activism, for believing in something. It was my daughter…she was asking me to help her with something she believed in … how could I be cynical?
But as I watched I still had nagging little doubts in my brain. I know people who have worked in international development. I had read about child soldiers in Africa. Surely – military intervention by the U.S. is not a solution. It won’t work – they’ve proved that time and again: Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq, not to mention Somalia – what a disaster that was. I guess my daughter is too young to have seen Blackhawk Down.
And another thing: why would we want to shine a light on a murdering madman like Kony? I was more interested in the would-be child soldier of the video: Jacob. How is he doing? Does he still feel suicidal? Did he get some help for his suffering and pain? What happens when a child is kidnapped, made to become a soldier or sex slave, then is rescued? How do they return to their families (if they haven’t been forced to murder or maim them yet?)
Shouldn’t the African people be the heroes of this story, not white filmmakers and their cute little kids?
But all of that I set aside in my rush of emotion while watching the Invisible Children video.
Another, more rational part of me, the part of me who used to work for a charity, admired Invisible Children for the following reasons:
- They didn’t dwell on the horror. I find “poverty pornography” distasteful. You know what I mean: the heart-rending photos of big-bellied brown children unable to wipe the flies away from their faces, or the woman cowering in the corner, shielding her children from an abusive partner. It’s shock and awe, and it only works for so long until people get overwhelmed and shut down.
- Instead, they told a story of friendship, they brought the conflict down to a human level.
- They pointed to a solution. A neat, tidy call to action that is creative, fun, and aimed perfectly at the target audience. If all you want to do is share the video, you can engage in some handy, instant “clicktivism.” If you want to do more, you can order a $30 kit and put up some posters with your friends. If you want to help “more,” you can donate on a per-month basis to the ongoing work of the charity.
- Of course, the celebrities don’t hurt either.
- And of course, it’s not enough, and there is more to Uganda and to Invisible Children than the video.
In a perfect world Invisible Children would learn valuable lessons and fold its money and talent into existing organizations who will tell the story justly. However, given that likely won’t happen, there is so much for activists to learn from Invisible Children.
The Occupy movement, for instance, demanded from many would-be supporters an untenable level of engagement and refused to point to solutions, or pointed to too many conflicting ones. (Not only that, but the human microphone thing only made me think of Monty Python’s Life of Brian: “You are all individuals,” says Brian to the mob gathered outside his door. “Yes, we are all individuals,” the mob replies in unison.)
The environmental movement has not been able to cross the divide from “we’re all doomed” to “look here, there’s hope” in a major way. As far as I’m concerned, “An Inconvenient Truth” showed the need. Now point me in the direction of the solution. Celebrate our victories, however small. Convince me the impossible can be done (something the Kony 2012 video does very well).
Along the way, can we please make it joyful? I’m prone to stress and depression at the best of times (along with most of the rest of North America), I want to be happy and hopeful, even when there are setbacks.
I KNOW we’re all doomed. I knew it from the first time I saw “If You Love this Planet.” I’m overwhelmed and I’m cynical. Don’t parade helpless victims and hopeless problems in front of me any more, give them a voice. Empower them. Don’t show me any more photos of dead baby albatrosses unless you can also illuminate the path to a better world.
Here’s something for leaders of causes to remember: people are only bitter and cynical because they still care.
I have a brand new empty nest. I just moved to a new city. I’m looking to give of myself and make some lasting relationships. I have a lot to give, but I’m cautious about where to spend my energy.
Show me how I can save the planet, give help to child soldiers, eradicate poverty in a joyful way, and I’ll work my fingers to the bone for your cause. Activate my compassion, but treat my activism with care, because my emotions are a limited resource. I hunger for joy and companionship as well as justice. Create communities where all those things are sustained and nurtured, and I will participate.
———
Here are some links I gathered last week that point to more on Uganda, Africa and Invisible Children:
- Kony 2012: what’s the real story?
- Rosebell Kagumire’s YouTube channel
- Links and information gathered by author Neil Gaiman, to whom I am grateful for spreading the word about the “other” side of the Invisible Children story.
- Taking ‘Kony 2012′ down a notch
- Visible Children: Kony 2012,viewed critically
Finally, if you want to donate to an international organization, might I suggest the following:
- Medecins sans frontières (Doctors Without Borders)
- Global Fund for Women
- Kiva







